video plays with montage of floyd saying he cant breathe and chauvin/other officers saying youre talking fine during restraint in car and on the... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:09
would take training into consideration mercil said when someone says they cant breathe but talking it means theyre breathing. compare testimony to... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:22
reasonable pd should do. would call ems within minute of struggle got code 2 for mouth injury. continued to kick them when on ground - saw mouth... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:18
consideration model: not a singular cycle, a cycle as humans literally make millions of decisions in a day. we are constantly doing this - human... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:26
these are tactics used for years? why? keeps people control, confined, until no longer resistant. a reasonable pd would also consider dept. policies... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:21
not a single use of force expert or pd that testifed said everything up until that point wasn't reasonable. reasonable efforts to overcome... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:57
vehicle rocks back and forth on milestone footage as struggle ensues with officers and floyd. cup foods sign is visible with car. plays until all... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:06
on other side of car. see floyd struggling with chauvin keng and lane. goes on other side. chauvin and kueng struggling as lane and thao watch. floyd... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:02
at precisely 8:18 chavuin goes on. keng lane and chauvin struggled with floyd from 8:18 until 8:19:12, little over a minute. doesn't seem like that... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:24
in fact officer is aware of policies and knows deescalation part of reasonable officer is to consider lack of compliance is deliberate attempt to... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:46
would observe white foam on mouth - under influence - using dispatch. making observations how would reasonable officers identify this. look at size... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:48
you can see *picture shows * chauvin walking up to squad car. what would reasonable pd see in this instant? could be defined *shows use of force... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:26
info gathering - decision making process of officer. don't go by me chang says - go over there. at that moment they don't know what's happening at... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像00:57
officer thao and lane arrive at cup foods *video plays. when we look at officer chang arriving first - time stamp, video plays again: across from cup... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:20
next slide: you hear someone being taken out of vehicle scene is code 4. so literally demonstrates couple of things - how quickly things can change -... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:11
body cam footage plays. so now we see pd officers respoding at 808. both scurry and chang described that initial interaction between keng lane and... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:44
talk about jenna scurry. exhibit 10 - jenna scurry call to officers. scurry informed you that chauvin as assigned to call on code 3 priority 1 call -... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:42
throughout cours of this trial they have focused on 9 min 29 secs. take analysis and put into context totatity of circumstances reasonable pd would... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:25
suspect was under influence they can take into consideration - dynamic situation. they take into account experience with sub at beg mid and end. try... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:29
read the instructions in its entirety, i submit to you the state has failed to meet proof beyond a reasonable doubt, mr.chauvin has been charged with... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:30
lawyers like to present arguments that favor themselves, and i have to address something that i think is important and prime example of what im... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:17
when you apply the standard of preponderance of evidence a single grain of sand tips the weight, it is used in a civil cases its a burden of proof... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:02
they gave it to you, randomly selected people from the community you got a summons in the mail all converged on one spot, sometimes when something is... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:17
unreasonable force not porportional and violated policy and the law and everything the minneapolis department stands for. awful but lawful, its just... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:31
i cant breathe crying out to help from the man in uniform, the defendant continued to twist his hand and grind his knee, i think is is passing out... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:37
dont get caught up in that dont miss the forrest for the trees, officer after officer raised their hand and told you the chief of police the 929... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:46
why didnt they do that? the conduct didnt warrant it, they just held him in this dangerous position, a reasonable pofficer doesnt do that, he follows... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:04
what would a reasonable officer do, you dont look at this through floyd perspective or bystander but look at the perspective of a reasonable officer... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像04:57
you fill find that element is beyond a reasonable doubt, he is guilty of all charges after all this there is a another question what this just okay... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:51
the bystanders looked themselves they took video strong probability to death and with the defendants training and knowledge and the common sense of... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:18
did the defdndant cause an act dangerous to others, absolutely the state proved that. a concious indifference that the dangerous act can cause, yes... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:03
he is staying put where we got him, he could have listened to bystanders his fellow officers or training, he knew better just didnt do better anyone... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:30
so when you consider the charge tey and break it down into parts the defendant caused the death of floyd he did, at the time of death he was... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像04:19
or had the purpose to prove harm to intended to violate the law, the only thing about intent is he applied force to floyd on purpse and its pretty... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:17
relieved the pressure, could have done cpr and duty to provide medical aid you arent supposed to just phone that in, no one started cpr and it... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:21
and the best doctor to do so, the drugs in his system didnt depress his oxygen, dr.smock who testified about excited delierum, there are no... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:40
just being in the prone position, dr.tobbin disagreed said the lung capacity was reduced by 25% and his testimony corrobrated the police training adn... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像04:03
he is the only person able to calcuate lung volume, dr.fowler couldnt do it, he spent years treating patients in extensive care, what this looks like... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:15
he died as low level oxygen which caused his heart to stop, his heart diease caused him to die it was the low level of oxygen we know it happened... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:46
we talked about the use of force and the unlawful restraint, 9 mins and 29 seconds thats what killed floyd thats what he died if you read yoru eyes... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:44
second element the defendant caused the death, causation there were substantial effect he is criminally liable for the consequences of the act that... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:19
in may 25th in hennepin county, as to the first element floyd died it was established by the emergency room witness and again you can consider these... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:13
but it is meant to be a guide to look at the different elemetns in a context, the judge read you what the law tells you and it breaks them down into... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:13
the proposition. that the car did you arent required to accept that or that it is the bystanders fault that distracted the defendant that at that... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:04
based on non-sense you arent required to accept that 9 mins and 29 seconds handcuff and restraint that after that, thats it not a use of force... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:02
the judge instructed you and you can go over it, you gotta go to medical school as jurors the free parking and a free law school education we will go... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:23
its a transatory position then you roll them on their side, proning him was completely unnecessary this is where the unnecessary force begins, they... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:40
and watch what happens, plays video, alright folks they get him out and he is handcuffed on his knees, not going anywhere there are 4 officers there... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:32
plays audio of floyd, he is trying to work himself to get in the car, you can see where the other officers come into the scene and 19 year veteran... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:15
they take him over to the car, floyd is a big guy you can see he is almost as big as officer lane, he is a big person the back of squad car is not,... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像00:54
lane orders floyd to put his hands on sterring wheel, thats compliance, thats not resistence the handcuffs werent properlydouble locked, too tight... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:43
he said im not trying to win, im scared but the defendant was trying to win, he wsant going to take a challenge to his authority he was training to... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:08
we have to cal the police on the police, the police are going to help with good reason, policing is the most noble profession it is and to be very... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:53
facing floyd that day did not require courage, all that was required was a little compassion and none was shown on that day, floyd said im not trying... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:58
desperately calling out, a grown man calling out for his mother a human being in that time and in that place while he was surrounded by faces he can... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:23
floyd was surrounded by people he cared about and who cared about him, throughout his life and childhood into his adulthood. on may 25, 2020 floyd... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:59
may it pleaase the court, conseul, member sof the jury, his name was george perry floyd jr he was born on, his parents george floyd sr. and larcenia... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:47
unless you found the state has proven beyond a reasonable doubt under the liability of crimes of another. charge 3 manslaughter in colpulable... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像04:55
enforcement of general criminal laws of minnesota and has power of arrest and charge a person in preventing a crime, the pd is a law enforcement... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像04:35
before closing arguments im going to give you the law, there is a copy on your seat...so members of the jury it is your duty to decide the questions... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:08
judge: i think we made a record of the different positions, mr shacfer and i will make a draft to give it to you tomorrow at 9, so we will act with... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像00:48
frank: we discusses not including the instruction of the circumstantial evidence that is in review. judge: i already decided that and im not granting... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:20
sundeep: the state asks that this isnturction be given to the jury upfront, and at a minimum that the lanaguage infringring 3.01 given to them at the... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像00:31
still on record the party agreed we can do this informally in the chamber okay mr chauvin you have the right to be present in the charge conference... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:02
the evidence rests you will listen to closing arguments and then debate we have to debate the law in my instructions we close on monday remember you... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:03
the most effective way to analyze the blood is the oxymeter right? right, you referenced there are 12-20 studies that an increase of pressure in the... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:40
you might recall discussing the hypopharynx on the potential of pressure to the back narrowing the hypopharynx? yes, do you recall him saying eh... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:16
as you prepare tot ell us why these results are unreliable could you tell the jury about oxygen saturation in the blood? when he went to hennepin... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:29
do you think this statement is reliable? no, why? i base it on the arterial blood gas when mr floyd was in hennepin county 11:22:59 - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像00:25
you studied this for 46 years? yes, were you able to hear testimony yesterday? yes i was, were you able to see this slide and particular sentence at... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:49
def: what i understand is, i think thats appropriate cross but if that is dr tobins opinion that have been disclosed earlier it is appropriate to say... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:02
pros: i havent talkes to dr tobin about what he says but what he comes up to without saying anything at all was we had the results on the oxygen... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像00:53
i find dr fowlers report gives the state sufficient notice that the carbon monoxide in george floyds blood could have affected his death dr fowler... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像03:03
lets talk about dr tobins opinion is it solely about the lab tests? it is solely talking about the carbon dioxide content of his blood it isnt just... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:22
what will dr tobin testify? mr floyds heart weight does not fall into a range that is abnormal he will talk about the broad pool of study in... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:33
dr tobin will testify on his opinion regarding dr fowlers cited studies he will say that based on lab tests done dr fowlers analysis does not hold... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:33
my recollection is dr tobin said it was the mechanism but they all agreed on the seizure? agreed but the mechanism being the point on what dr tobin... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像01:39
the fact the state didnt consider this before and considers this in the middle fo trial i did receive dr tobins rebuttle points 3 i dont address as... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:04
i received these test results this morning as i understand dr fowler is on an airplane i have difficulty reaching him i have people looking on this... - 德里克·沙文 個影片檔及 b 捲影像02:36
